
So, at last, the first huge rewrite of my YA manuscript is done. Whew. What I ride! And yes it did involve sweat and tears but fortunately no blood – well, at least not mine.
Several months ago I sent the manuscript (MS) which had gone through several fairly major edits and has been a work in progress for a about three years, to the Cornerstones writing agency for an in-depth review. I’d had pretty good feedback from writing partners and friends but I knew the MS still needed work and I needed the right input to do that work.
What I wasn’t remotely prepared for were the 18 pages of criticism that came back – criticism that initially left me gutted and thoroughly daunted - and chucking not a few hissy fits. But I’d asked for the criticism and I’d paid some serious dosh for it, so it was in my best interests to take it on board. Let it not be said that being a writer doesn’t involve a pragmatic approach and a thick skin.
I sat with the criticism for a couple of months, letting it stew in my mind, wondering how the hell I was ever going to make the MS right – and eventually decided that instead of trying to “fix it”, I’d hold the original story in my mind and start from scratch.
In many ways it’s been like writing a new novel. I've done mountains of new research and the plot has been considerably revised – as was required. The narrative voice has changed substantially, as was required. The writing is tighter than before and I’ve addressed issues of repetition, too much introspection, clichés, telling not showing – and, I’ve killed about 36 000 words. Yep, the new version is much, much leaner.
The curious thing is that I’ve always said I hate editing and rewriting, but this was a blast – a process, which, although I found difficult at times, I knew was critical to my journey of becoming a better writer. Let it not be said that this business doesn’t involve some really hard work and lots of learning. To anyone who thinks they can “just” write a book – think again, very, very carefully – especially in today’s competitive and depressed market. It takes, I’m sure, more than just a little bit of madness to be a writer. I consider myself a case in point…
In the process of this rewrite though, I think the thing that delighted me the most was realizing just how passionate I am about writing. Like most writers, I guess, I have my up days and my down days but I find when I’m in the flow of a story, gripped by words, I soar. Actually, to be honest, I am away with the fairies and get totally blissed out. Ha, who needs sex and drugs and rock ‘n roll when you get such a high from scribbling. We won’t talk about the down days, ‘cos they’re just too miserable for words.
A new experience for me in the process of the rewrite was something I’ve often read about - the quest for the perfect word, the perfect sentence. It made me wonder, as I grappled in the search for the right strong nouns and strong verbs how on earth German writers, with their limited vocabulary, manage! Sheesh, am I glad to be writing in English!
Funny thing is, now that the first big rewrite is finished, how totally flat I feel. Postnatal syndrome of some sort, I suspect...
But what next? Well, I’ll leave the manuscript for a week or so and then I’ll go back and do a thorough edit, picking up any gremlins that may still be in there based on the initial feedback about my writing style. And then it will probably go back to Cornerstones for further input.
I'm also off to a writing conference in the UK in November and will be taking part in both a critique session with fellow writers and have signed up for a review with either an agent or an editor. And after that, well, we'll see.
Meanwhile, I’ve got another manuscript that needs a rewrite, a book cover to design for a competition, a synopsis and a blurb to write.
So yeah, more busy, which means continued erratic blogging! But a girl’s gotta do what a girl’s gotta do!
31 comments:
Well if your written your book anything like your blog then is will be a runaway success... it is always such a joy to come here and read your words.
Can't wait for November!!
xx
Aw, you're a sweetie! But tt's funny you know, FireByrd, writing the blog is in a whole different style - much easier for me. Writing for older teens is a damned side more challenging - I honestly think writing for adults is a whole lot simpler!
And me too!!! Really looking forward to November! :-) xx
"Like most writers, I guess, I have my up days and my down days but I find when I’m in the flow of a story, gripped by words, I soar."...isn't it just the greatest when this happens!
Congratulations, Vanilla! Writing for older teenagers must be very complex...so many different moods from the characters to explore.
All the best in this latest rewrite!
Congratulations on your rebirth.
This is fantastic news. I'm so happy for you, really. The rewrites are what writing is really about, I think. But it can be so exhausting and scary. I'm thrilled it's gone so well for you!
Glad to hear to have finished your rewrite. Your blogger friends are rooting for you.
Wonderful that you've finally 'put it to bed' lets hope it eventually gets wings and flies. As for paying for criticism . . .wouldnt mind that job!
Best of luck to your Dear Vanilla, in your quest for the perfect word, perfect sentence. You have such a way with words and I can't wait to read it once complete!
xox
way to go, nicky... :)
i'm the same way, when i get in a 'groove', the writing soars... other times it just sours!
Congrats!!! It is great to hear that you have achieved this, and that you have so much else going on in the writing/creative pipeline!
From September to December this year I will be posting a series of tips written by the British author Zadie Smith in an essay for the Guardian on what makes a good writer. I obtained permission from the paper to publish it on my blog and at the moment another Cuban blogger is doing the illustrations for the columns. Your tale reminded me of one of the examples of Zadie mentions and the fact that you have thick skin is a great attribute. I just wonder sometimes how much those critics wanted you to be 'them' and how much of yourself you have to jettison to reach a middle point. I enjoyed your short story, too. Excellent beginning. Many thanks.
Greetings from London.
PS: Word verification 'apear' ('to climb down' in Spanish :-D)
Good luck with those gremlins. I admire your passion and hard work. I probably would've moved to a new story.
congrats and kudos! rewrites are sometimes harder than the first draft. i just finished an epic short story and discovered a kick-arse writing site on the same day, so i'm stoked too! wordhustler.com. thx!
I loved your description of soaring when the writing flows! Oh, yeah. That's my favorite moment, too.
A tip to make the editing process even better: check out the AutoCrit Editing Wizard. It finds lots of those problems that our too-familiar eyes miss.
I couldn't live without it :-)
Yes, criticism is always painful.But unless it's spitefully motivated it's always worth taking on board. Good luck with the leaner meaner MS!
Wow! Congrats on the complete rewrite. I have to say, I don't think I'd be able to do it.
The novel I'm currently shopping around took me a couple years and about 4 or 5 drafts to get to where it is. On my bad days, I still think it bites the big one.
But if I get rejected from every agency I submit to, I don't think I'd have it in me to rewrite the novel from scratch. I'm sorta lazy.
I wish you the best with this draft! :-)
Congrats! I'm so pleased the re-write has given you so much.
I think it's very brave to have your work criticised. I'm not sure I want that for mine but I know to expect lots of criticism and I'm not looking forward to it. Well done for ploughing on and doing a rewrite. I am sure your efforts will pay off.
CJ xx
So proud of you that you finished!! WOO HOO!!!
18 pages of criticism? Don't know if I could have handled that.
Take the break and then back to it again. Great job! YAY!!!!
HUGS!
XOXO
oh dear that just sounds like alot of work, but then it goes to show why you are such a good writer, you know what to do with that criticism.
being married to a writer and editor i have seen both sides of this process, it is not for the faint of heart.
you are Nicky the lion heart my dear.
don't forget your airborne on the november trip ☺
I've just spent ages catching up on all I have missed over the last few days!! I adored the short story you entered for the competition...the twist at the end was jaw dropping and I loved your descriptions in 'In Times of Drought'!!
Your a very talented lady and I already know I'm going to love your book :-)
Ohhh, your coming over in November...any chance you might be able to fit me in for a coffee? Would be fab to meet you!!
C x
Hello :) I would just like to say that I am a teenager, and I love to write stories. I am currently writing one right now, on blogger. I would appreciate it very much if you could read it and comment what you think. Don't be scared to be a critic :] . I have gotten the first chapter so far. [They are labeled: Chapter one part one, and chapter one part two.]
If you do find the time to read it, then you will have to scroll down to the bottom post, because that is where the story starts. The top post is the last half of chapter one.
Once again, it would be very much appreciated. Thank you, have a good day =]
Rachelle
The url is:
lillyofthevalleystory.blogspot.com
I liken it to ripping your newborn baby apart - but you usually end up with something better!
Am very impressed - well done, Vanilla. Keep at it :)
Deep in writing myself, av, so not circulating on blogs as much these days.
Best of luck to you and 'bonne continuation.'
Thank you so much for commenting. I love getting advice from other writers.
--Rachelle
Well done on the rewrite/revision, Vanilla. Can't wait to hear the ms is on its way to an agent!
Love the Selena's Moon picture.
Where in UK is the conf? It's probably down south not 'oop north' but if it's anywhere near Manchester let me know.
xxPat
Congrats, Vanilla! I'm very happy for you!
I feel a connection with you as a writer going through the editing and revision process. I checked out Cornerstone's website and wondered if more people send their MS to an agency like theirs, rather than hiring a freelance editor who might also have agent connections. Just curious.
I know how you feel. I'm currently doing the same with my novel (after sending the first three chapters to a critique service). I'm doing more research and more rewrites, but it'll definitely be worth it in the long run.
Well done, and I wish you all the best with it.
Post a Comment