Thursday, October 2, 2008

Who'd be a writer, eh?

A composite of images created when I first started writing the novel - it helps one to "see" and "feel" the characters and the mood of the story


There is, I have to tell you, only one place you can go after “up” – and that’s down. You may recall the post from last Friday, with me on a focused, wild high of editing – feeling super optimistic about my novel. Hmm, yes, well… Several hours later I was down in the black hole of hopelessness.

I’d been buoyed up by news earlier in the week that the vampire trend which has been so big in the US was set to hit the UK and although my novel is not specifically a vampire novel it does fall into the paranormal genre. I prefer to think of the story as a coming of age tale. The vampire element, though fundamental to the story is not what the story is “all about” – it’s the means, rather than the end. It’s the journey of self-discovery and personal growth that is critical to the plot - but it does need the specific paranormal genre in which it is set in order to work.

Anyway, I contacted a couple of writing friends in the UK to get their view on what I’d heard and was told, actually, if you think about it, if the trend is about to hit the UK, this means that editors have already done the acquisitions. You have to bear in mind the two year lead in time. Anything that is about to hit the street now was acquired two years ago. In a nutshell, Vanilla, duckie, you’ve missed the boat.

Bugger, damn and far more colourful words sprang to mind. I wouldn’t have minded quite so much if a) I'd had set out to write to a trend and b) if I’d only written the first draft last week. But the thing was I wasn't writing to a trend and the first draft of the novel was written between February and April of 2006 (bang on trend target!).

So here I sit with my now edited and re-re-re-edited manuscript, facing the likelihood that even if it is any good (and personally, I think it is), that no one will want to take it on because its “missed the trend”. Pooh.

The thing is, where to now? One view is to put the manuscript aside and leave it until “later”. The other view is to submit it anyway and see what happens.

Fortunately, I am working on another manuscript and am thinking maybe I should just focus on that and get that ready for submission. But when you’ve put so much work into something it seems criminal to just walk away from it – and besides, I have a character who is having a major sulk at me and I feel really bad about her. She wants to be out there – and since she has all sorts of superhuman powers I’m a wee bit worried about what she might do to me!

Of course, there are lessons that come out of everything and in this instance, the writing lessons aside (more on that another time), the thing that struck me most forcibly is the choice I have in responding to the situation. Although my initial reaction was woe, doom and gloom, I realised too that I could choose not to be upset about it – and since not being upset is far nicer than being miserable, that’s what I chose to do.

You see, one can take two views on everything – the external, of the world, view and the internal, place of inner stillness, view. The one is ego dominated, the other is soul dominated. I opted for the latter. It’s ultimately, I believe, more sensible and puts one back on a level base from which to decide how to move forward. Much better, I think, that stonking around and feeling deeply sorry for oneself!

And as to what I’m going to do – well, I’ll let you know just as soon as I’ve figured it out! For now, I'm working on getting the other manuscript edited.

27 comments:

Rambler said...

Vanilla...I guess there would be nothing like missing the trend..if it all anything..I am sure your book will set a new trend..so go for it ..

Rambler said...

Vanilla...I guess there would be nothing like missing the trend..if it all anything..I am sure your book will set a new trend..so go for it ..

Baino said...

Go on submit it anyway as long as you can cope with the possibility it might not get wings and fly. Too much hard work to go letting it catch dust on the shelf.I do know of a writer who's publishing herself and another who's going through the same painful edits and re-edits in red pen of all things! Chin ups sweets, remember you live to write, not write to live! I'm sure it's wonderful!

Val said...

I agree, stay with it. View those others that were purchased two years ago and building a market for yours to coast in on..and you get to watch andlearn from the reaction to theirs. anyway i am sure yours will be unique, individual and a fresh view on the movement! best of luck.... let us know where we can find a copy :-)

SueG said...

I really think you have to go ahead and finish/submit your manuscript. You've worked so hard. You know it's good. It deserves a chance at a life. And anyway, the whole trend thing is just hearsay, isn't it? This stuff is so fickle. All you can do is do your best work and force the world (or even a little bit of it) to take a look. Go for it!

Angela said...

Astrid Lindgren and Mrs. Harry Potter were rejected, too! It`s a good sign! There are other publishers, aren`t there?? I would buy your book! I think you are a very good writer, and I MEAN that. Please don`t let anyone discourage you, all your blog fans think you are great. Have you read the Terry Pratchett books? Full of vampires, and sooo successful. I am virtually pushing you in the side, saying, C`mon, BELIEVE in your story, and offer it again! Will soon hear your good news I`m sure!

Candy Gourlay said...

it's only a trend ... and the cycle might be short!

Absolute Vanilla (and Atyllah) said...

Yep, I will go for it, Rambler - there's not too much to lose, I don't think :-)

I think I've actually found the way forward, Bains - the cool thing is that as the entire publishing world is changing, so writers are finding themselves with more and more options - like self publishing, publishing online etc. More than one way to skin that wicked cat ;-) - though, I'll probably still head the "traditional" route, for now.

The trouble with the genre, Val, is that it's saturated the market. This happens when publishers find the huge "next big thing" - they thing it to death and then suddenly don't want anymore. But thanks for the good luck and I'll certainly keep you posted! ;-)

Yep, my main character reckons she deserves a chance of life too, Sue - in fact she keeps walking past and kicking me. I didn't know characters could come to life quite so vigourously! Ouch! :-) And I suppose too, the old adage must hold true - you have to write what you need and want to write, if you write solely "for the market" you'll drive yourself bonkers.

Rejection is very much part of a writer's life indeed, Angela - no question about that. And thanks for the support, hugely appreciated.
As for Terry Pratchett, LOVE Terry Pratchett - especially the vampires and witches! :-) And don't worry, I do believe in my story, it's just the market I worry about! ;-)

Well, the reality of the thing says, Candy that vampires have been popular since Roman times - and there's always a vampire/paranormal cult fringe thing - what one's currently seen though, courtesy of Kostova's The Historian and Meyer's Twilight series is a sudden rush into the mainstream of paranormal novel. It will pass and then only the really good vampire books will find a home - look at the Anne Rice or Buffy phenomenon, it just goes on.
Erm, does this sound like I'm trying to convince myself? :-)

JaneyV said...

Look Honey Pie! (Stern words to follow). Do NOT (and I repeat) NOT sit on that baby because some stupid trend has given you the willies. Trust your story. Trust your characters. If they are good enough then they won't need a stoopido trend. A strong novel will stand on its own merits. Always. And even if you are worried that publishers or agents are trend-watching, the fact is they will still be able to tell that you are a fantastic writer from your MS even if they want to pass on it right now. It can still open doors.

So submit your ass off. Right now. No second guessing. Believe.

BTW brilliant visual!

Wuv you xxx

R.L. Bourges said...

I usually read other people's comments first but a bit short on time today. I say: forget the trend issue. If you believe in your story, tweak your cover letter to focus on whatever you think is the strongest selling point and find out. I know, believe me I know. That's still what I'd do with it.
btw I do that too - build up visual files that give me the mood or the feel of what I'm writing. Helps, doesn't it?

best, av, keep on pluggin'

i am storm. said...

everything about the trends is just 'noise'. something to distract you from your course.

i think you are making the right decision by continuing on. do what is right for you. a good book stands on its own -- it does not need the gimmick of a trend to support it.

i wish you pride, accomplishment and success,

storm

Taffiny said...

I would submit it. Your book wouldn't be the first published in a trend, but that doesn't mean it would have to miss the trend entirely. The peak of a trend might have a time frame, but still that doesn't mean books about vampires wont be published after a peak. (and yours has that as another layer to a coming of age story, and is not the whole point of it)

I go through the same ups and downs, from optimism to desolation, when it comes to my stories. I can think of no trend I could be part of, but still I worry too about missing the boat, that sweet time period when what I have to give, is most likely to be well received (or seen at all).

It is frustrating when you know you have been working on something for years, then the work of others comes out, and it would seem like your ideas came from theirs. I started Echo over 10 years ago, and I get this pang of terror whenever any story is published that I feel in any way is telling the story I am trying to tell. I get so mad at myself for taking so long, perhaps so long that what I have to offer becomes obsolete. But precisely because it has taken me so long to get this far, I know no matter what, no matter how unlikely I am to ever get published, still I must go on, must keep trying to move ahead. My characters like yours, insist upon it. That I do all I can to offer them a chance to be in the world. You are now in the position of being able to say no to yourself, to say no your story before someone else can. I say, why would you? To yourelf you say yes, if you find out (after as many submissions as your age, that it will not be published) that publishers say no, then you work on accepting (or trying to cirumvent) no at that point. (not now, not before, why on earth would you accept no now?)

This is just the opinion of an unpublished writer, but I have made it my creed and it helps me. Maybe in the future I will learn to write to markets, and trends, right now I am still learning how to write what is within my heart, the stories I feel (if any) that I am meant to tell. And I am telling myself Yes. Yes to me, yes to my stories, yes to me dream, yes to working hard trying to get there. I will not be the one to say no.

JaneyV said...

I apologise for the tone of my earlier comment. I'd just come home from telling 4-year olds off for the entire morning and I hadn't got out of character yet!

What I meant to sat was "I believe in you… and your vampires."

Absolute Vanilla (and Atyllah) said...

Dear Teacher, yes, that's you, Janey, many thanks for the valuable kick up the bum, it is in fact, well appreciated and I really don't mind you being all teachery with me. Would you like an apple?
BTW, wuv u 2 ;-)

Thanks for the vote of support, RLB - and yes, it does make a huge difference having visuals to work with when writing - at any one time I've got all sorts of images stuck up on my pinboard and saved to my hard drive!

Oh thanks, Storm, you're a honey. You're right, of course, a good book will always stand on it's own merit, though I am conscious too of how many good books just never make it to publication because whims and trends and luck do play such a fundamental part in the process. Still, one carries on because one must.

Taff, I think the most critical point that you make is that we have to write the stories that have to be written, the ones in our heart, the ones that wing their way to us. And in writing them, we have to do the best we can, if that takes one year or ten years. We have to believe in our story, our characters and ourself - and let's face it, being a writer is all about perseverance and having a hide like a rhinocerous!
We'll both keep at it then!
Thank you so much for all your words and thoughts, they're much appreciated.
xxx

Ropi said...

Well good luck with your novel. In Hungary you would have easier task because novel (novella) means short story and it is easier to write.

Marion said...

Go for it anyway, trend or not. Whenever I feel discouraged, I head for the New Book section at my library, and read the blurbs and first pages on the books sitting there...you know, the books the publishers LIKED. Some of them are good, but many, many, many are just garbage. OK, I'm in the US, but I believe the publishers are all into covers that jump out at the potential reader, often with little inside to match those covers. Don't give up...

Absolute Vanilla (and Atyllah) said...

It's funny you know, Ropi, I actually find it easier to write a full length story as opposed to writing a short story.

You're right, Marion, there is very much a thing about publishers going for "flashy" covers that will grab attention - it's all part of the marketing.
And no, I won't give up, I can't - I live to write, it would seem :-)

Marie said...

Forget about trends. You worked so hard on your story, so I think you should just take a chance and send it out. You never know.

As I've nearly finished writing a vampire novel, I'm in the same boat as you. But I believe in my story (as I'm sure you do), and I've also worked so hard on it, so I'm definitely not going to forget about it just because of some trend.

Good luck!

*~*{Sameera}*~* said...

Better late than never dear.I am keeping my fingers crossed for you.All the very best! :)

*HUGS*

Bonnie Jacobs said...

Trends don't follow timetables, dear heart, so go for it! This may actually be the perfect time, but if you don't give your story a chance, you'll never know.

Steve said...

I wouldn't worry about trends. Just believe in yourself and believe in your work.

If it was me I would submit it. Then I would forget all about it, focus on something new, and only worry about it when I got a reply. And if the work was rejected I'd submit it elsewhere and then focus on something else again.

lettuce said...

i hope you're going to go for it. And if it doesn't get anywhere now, try again in a year or so.

I guess i don't know much about publishing and trends.
But the paranormal/vampire thing seems to me to never really go off trend.... i'm going to be watching the Company of Wolves with some students soon and discussing it. Some mythologies go on and on and seem never to lose their appeal

Absolute Vanilla (and Atyllah) said...

You're right, Marie, I've got to at least give it a chance - if I don't, I suspect my main character may come and do something nasty to me in the dead of night! Thanks for the encouragement!

Thanks, Sameera, you're a honey! (((HUGS)))

You're right, Bonnie, if I don't give it a go, I'll never know.

Yep, Steve, I think you're spot on right! :-) So best I get those envelopes ready and best I keep at the new WIP! And the one that's starting to brew for after that!

I think that's a key thing, Lettuce, the paranormal thing is consistently popular but like all things it goes in cycles in terms of the level of popularity. I think the thing is though, it has less to do with what the reading public wants and considerably more to do with what publishers feel that reading public should have - and therein lies the rub!

Lane said...

Agree with all the other comments. Go ahead and submit it. You book deserves its chance and your characters won't leave you alone until you do.

I think the paranormal trend hasn't even peaked yet and I heard only the other day that agents are still on the lookout.

So do. Do!

Minx said...

Write, write, write, submit, have lunch, write, write, write, submit.....

Debi said...

They've all said it but I'm going to say it too. Don't try to second guess trends and markets. That way madness lies.

You've written the book you needed to write so you've already achieved something really special. The next stage is to release it into the world and see if anyone else sees its potential.

That will be their decision and no amount of guessing can give you an absolute certainty of what they're looking for. Only one way to find out.

And don't forget that the current wisdom is that you have to have at least 30 rejections before you can assume there's something intrinsically wrong with your MS!

Absolute Vanilla (and Atyllah) said...

You're right, Lane, these particular characters won't leave me alone until I've given them a good chance, so I guess I'd better get on the submissions bandwagon! And very gratifying to hear that there are still agents looking for paranormal stuff. Thanks!

I am, I am, Minx write, write, writing!

Yes, Debi, you're right, that way does lie madness - no doubt about it.
30 rejections, eh? Well, guess I'd better get cracking!
Thanks so much for your input, I really appreciate it!