I’m not sure what happened to the dream of the Rainbow Nation but I think it’s probably safe to say both dream and rainbow have vanished. The past few weeks have been “interesting” to say the least. The xenophobic violence that reared its ugly head killing about 62 people, injuring some 670 and displacing more than 100 000 people has left many of us perplexed. D and I have had long discussions as to what may lie behind the inexplicable display of violence that has been experienced. Could it be sociological? Yes. Could it be theological? Yes. Is it the result of socio-economic policies? Yes. Is it the result of high expectations fuelled by lack of delivery? Yes. Is it the result of political lethargy? Yes. Is the result of a lack of education? Yes. It is all these things but it is also more – and it is the more that is almost too frightening to put into words. It is a barbarism and brutality that smacks primarily of Hitler’s Germany but also of Pol Pot’s Cambodia and Milosevic’s Serbia. It speaks of a baseness in the human psyche – the shadow self, the untamed beast.
Take this story and make sense of it if you can.
A Somali shop owner lived in one of the Cape Town townships/shantytowns for over seven years. He lent his predominantly Xhosa neighbours money, did their shopping when they’ve were unable to, gave their children sweets. He was a part of their community and his prices were better than the supermarkets. Yet there he stood in his shop two weeks ago when his neighbour walked into the shop and started toyi-toyi-ing. He said to her “Sisi [sister], you must sing when you dance,” not realising that her dance was a Judas kiss which brought all his other neighbours into the shop. His neighbours looted the shop, burnt it down and chased him from his home and neighbourhood screaming “Hamba amakwerekwere, hamba!” (Go, foreigner, go!)
There is no logic in this action. This man had done nothing to them. In fact, he had helped them, yet this was how they repaid him – by turning on him and destroying everything he had.
It’s not an isolated incident. In recent weeks events like this have unfolded across South Africa.
Angela’s husband has experienced much the same. For two years he has lived amongst his neighbours, renting a room from a local woman. As a qualified welder running his own business, he has created burglar bars, sliding gates and security gates for the people he lives amongst. Yet, on top of never wanting to pay him (after all, why should they pay a foreigner), two weeks ago they looted the workshop where he worked and stole most of his equipment. He now has to either start from scratch or find employment with a company. The irony is, these same locals are now asking when he'll come back and do more burglar bars for him. As he says, he doesn't want to go back, it's not safe and will never be. Foreigners, he says, are natural targets from local criminal elements - and others, simply because they're foreign
As events have unfolded, foreigners across South Africa have been necklaced and burnt to death, they’ve been attacked and victimized, they’ve had their belongings stolen or burnt. Many fled with just the clothes on their back. Locals have shown a complete lack of human compassion, understanding - and basic humanity. A negative energy which has touched everyone has pervaded the country like an unexpected, rampant cancer. Of course, one might say it was not that unexpected. And it wasn’t – it’s been waiting to happen – it started happening five years ago (and that’s without mentioning South Africa’s long history of ethnic violence). But the government in its “wisdom” has, as ever, failed to act - and continues to do too little, too late.
It would, of course, be gloriously easy to say, as so many do, “Oh, this is the legacy of apartheid.” To that, I say, "Rubbish! Wake up and smell the roses." Yes, of course, apartheid was a deeply dehumanizing system, no one denies that, of course it has left scars. But we are fourteen years on and huge efforts have been made to heal the rifts. Yet today, racism is more alive and well in South Africa than it has ever been. It is conceivably far worse than ever.
Angela’s husband and I were chatting this morning.
“You know what they say in the townships,” he said, “why they want this Zuma as president? Because they say he is going to chase away the whites. They don’t want whites in South Africa, they want only themselves, they hate everyone else. They look to Zimbabwe and they say, yes, that Mugabe, he has the right idea, he chased away the whites. They’re mad, these people, crazy. They’re ignorant. They don’t know what the reality will be. They will have nothing. South Africa will end up like Zimbabwe – and unlike Zimbabweans, these South Africans they don’t want to work, they don’t know how to work. They want everything, but it must be given to them for nothing.”
My own experience of many South Africans bears this out. The resentment and hatred continues to brood and brew. It is targeted at minority ethnic groups, irrespective of colour or creed. Alongside it the culture of entitlement and non-payment continues to grow.
“You know,” said Angela’s husband, “they were attacking everyone they saw when we left. It didn’t matter that you were black, if you were blacker than them, they attacked you. Even their own people. It was only when people could prove they spoke their language that they stopped beating them, but everyone else – local people and foreigners – who didn’t speak their language, they attacked, even the old ladies, the grandmothers.”
(Do take into account that South Africa has 11 official languages and eight non official languages...)
There is a strong sense among those I speak to that this violence is but the beginning. That it will, in time, spread from attacks on foreigners to attacks on the Indian, “coloured” (mixed race), white and other smaller ethnic populations.
The ANC government has had fourteen years to make a difference – and it has failed miserably. President Thabo Mbeki continues to argue that there is no crisis in Zimbabwe. I suspect he still believes that AIDS is the white man’s hex on the black man and that it can be cured by the African potato and a goodly dose of garlic. He has presided over an education system which is in tatters, health services which have failed miserably, and borders that are as porous as sieves. The fact that it took him two weeks to act and another two and a half weeks to speak out against the xenophobia, also speaks volumes, as does his refusal to invite the UN to lend assistance to the thousands of refugees housed in tented camps in the middle of a wet and cold winter. One can only assume that along with Bob from up North, he’s done a deal with the devil (or maybe the Chinese). Of course, as to his successor, Jacob Zuma, currently facing charges of fraud and corruption (which he and his cronies are doing their level best to quash), I think it would be safe to say, he’ll go with the highest bidder. As it is, his message changes from day to day depending on what any given audience wishes to hear.
Those who think the writing isn’t on the wall for the “Rainbow Nation” are surely living in a fool’s paradise whilst imitating the good old ostrich.
27 comments:
thank you for this long, intelligent and well-written analysis of the situation in south africa... where the madness comes from and why it should be is one of the longer running mysteries of the human race since it turns up so often and so rampantly occasionally...
of course there's safety in numbers, but when the crowd goes insane and displays such totally dysfunctional behaviour you'd wonder where you could be safe at all... so sad when you think that solid, formalised education for all could have provided the necessary insights to prevent such distressing behaviour (my take)...
Powerful post. You tell it like it is AV. I may come back with more when I've had time to reflect.
AV you should publish this. We're hearing much more about the situation here now but it's a news story, nobody outside SA seems interested in taking any action. I watched a documentary last night in fact about a white woman in Jburg who's cooking for 1000 refugees out of her own pocket because nobody else was feeding these people. You're right, it's a combination of a multitude of sins . .reminiscent of Kosovo too where neighbours suddenly pounced upon each other. The situation seems hopeless when you have a Govt that will not take affirmative action and no alternative president to allay the fears of ethnic minorities. I think it's time for social and Church leaders to speak up since the Govt. is so ineffective.
AV dearest, thank you for sharing. Is it safe to assume that you are in fact in a safe place? What are you guys going to do, as this violence spreads (again assuming government is not going to do much about it in the short term)? I don't mean to sound negative but are you worried about your family's safety?
It is terrible times all around the world, whether it be violence, war, or simply unaffordable food, etc prices for many poor people in a lot of countries.
It is time the silent majority (that's the harmless, lovely people sitting in their homes and contemplating the situation in the world) do something, maybe by acting on the interconnectedness you have written a while back.
Must there be petrol in a country for the eyes of the world to turn to it??????????
'Take this story and make sense of it if you can.'
Nope, I can't make any sense of it. If it were a film it would be a real tear-jerker.
I had no idea what 'necklacing' was until I followed the link. I might have guessed it was hanging or something like that, I would never have guessed what it really is. Very nasty.
i'm kind of wordless but don't want to just say nothing.
I think our news over here is pretty good on international events, but we're not getting anything much on this. You could email it to Channel 4 news?
this makes me ashamed of my recent moanings about not much
PS do you know anything about Rene Girard's scapegoating theories? they seem to fit the picture so often. Though its stronger on the how than the why, i think
Thanks, Bart. I agree, getting to the root of the madness is definitely one of the longer running mysteries of humanity. I have my theories, but...
And you're right, education could have made the world of difference.
Thanks, Ernest - look forward to hearing your thoughts.
Baino, pieces like mine are being published pretty much all over SA at present. I don't think there's anyone who doesn't have a view. I think all over SA there are people quietly getting with helping wherever they can. The problem now is there is violence flaring inside the camps - refugees/foreigners are insisting on UN intervention and the police and government are not interested and so there has been still more violence, but now stemming from a different source. Foreigners are also starting to retaliate. And meanwhile it just gets colder and wetter. And as far as I can see, while certain sectors make plenty of noise, no one is really standing up to Government - which is interesting - mostly, I suspect because the legacy of SAs own impoverished hangs above like the proverbial sword of Damacles...
Gaye, thanks for the concern, we're as safe as anyone is safe in a crime ridden country. The violence has been restricted to the townships though of course, whether in time, it will spread from there, is anyone's guess. Widespread civil unrest is something that is pretty much in everyone's thoughts at present - when that happens, if it does, then safety will be a real issue. I hope to be gone before then.
Necklacing is one of the most heinous sins, Steve - it's hard to imagine the barbarism that inspires it.
We're each where we need to be, Lettuce, each dealing with what the individual journey dishes out. Everything is relative - so don't feel bad about the space you find yourself in. No, I haven't heard of Rene Girard's scapegoating theories - but will go off for a quick google. I think the why of these things is always very difficult to understand.
Me again. I think in part we have the uncomfortable collision between political philosophy and pragmatics.
The pragmatics are that in many pre-independence countries, the black populace, though not "free", was materially better off than now. In fact "pre-freedom" infant mortality in SA in 1960 was not achieved by Africa as a whole until 1990 (UNECA stats).
As for the "I want it all and I want it now" mentality ... well it may be more extreme but not so different to the expectation and dependency cultures you will find in parts of Europe.
What is important, though, and I feel this runs through your thinking, is to be brave enough to say "Sure, you had it rough, and it was wrong, but that doesn't mean you can have it without self restraint and hard work now". And this the ruling classes, in Zim and SA, seem to be unable to bring themselves to do.
thanks for the post. didnt knw it was so bad there. some indians living in SA were featured in some stories in papers here. followed the link to the necklacing story on wiki. lynchin is pretty common in the rural areas in india. ur story is very powerful.
In my opinion it is better to prevent agression than thinking what caused it.
at a much more contained level (or, at least, containable) the outbreaks of violence in the French suburbs follow the same, senseless path of destruction. At that level, there is no friend or ennemy, just a raw spurting of bottled up energy, whatever the trigger may have been.
I'm happy to read that you are relatively safe. But your thoughts of "where to next" strike me as warranted, to put it mildly.
best
I'd never heard of necklacing before - what a terrible practice.
Thanks for this post, Vanilla. I'd almost certainly be oblivious to the situation there, otherwise.
Your points are relevant and spot on Ernest. I constantly have a sense of "needing to catch up" and yet it goes with the unwillingness to do what needs to be done in order to catch up. We don't evolve and develop overnight, it's a process - and I think it's the process that many desire to bypass - but trying to do so comes at such a tremendous cost.
It's a story that seems to have only made world headlines in certain places, Puresunshine - but for us, it's just everywhere.
Ropi, I think sometimes one needs to understand what causes the aggression in order to prevent it. Not understanding it is like trying to treat an illness without understanding it's root cause.
I think you make a critical point, Lee - violence of this nature knows no bounds - it can spring up anywhere, anytime and with devastating consequences. Triggers may vary but the it's always the same fundamental fear that is tapped into and which spills over in to such behaviour.
As to where to next - that's very much a work in progress and we're moving steadily towards leaving.
It is a vile practice, Rob - no question there - and I'm glad if the post shed some light for you.
Vanilla - Thanks again for taking the time to teach the rest of us about what's actually going on in this world (or at least your corner of it). The mindlessness of it all is, to me, very reminiscent of Kosovo and Rwanda particularly. It frightens me to death to consider that people who have lived and worked beside each other, not only peacefully, but in a friendly way, can turn on a dime into a barbarous mob spewing murder and hatred. I simply don't understand the mental processes involved. Perhaps there are none. Perhaps this mob violence bypasses reason and goes straight to a primeval instinct for war and bloodshed when certain conditions come into play. But what are those conditions? My instincts are that there are master manipulators at play here. Who starts the whispers that snowball into war cries?
It's beyond me.
As for the image of a rainbow nation .... the metaphor was always a flawed one. A rainbow is simply a beautiful optical illusion. It is transient and illusive.
I do however believe in the notion that human beings of all hues can coexist peacefully and respectfully with one another. I think it's important to remain hopeful.
In spite of everything I still believe people are basically good at heart"
Maybe Anne Frank was right?
a very sobering insider view of what is happening in south africa. thank you for sharing this. it is very troubling, perplexing, and so very tragic.
the story of the somali shop owner broke my heart.
thoughts of loving kindness to you and ALL your country-people - let us hope and pray that the dream of a rainbow nation can once again take hold and guide the hearts and actions of the people.
in reading this I had this flash of a sci-fi movie that we watched a while ago, I am legend with will smith - it was about a terrible plague that turned humans into monsters.... art imitating life
There are words...none strong enough that I can find...to describe my feelings right now. This was a powerful and heart-wrenching post. I think most of the world is too sheltered from these truths and more need to hear about the ongoing daily strife experienced there. I'm so sorry for everyone affected by this, especially when they are just trying to make an honest living and do good for their family and friends.
I'm also very much reminded of Kosovo and Rwanda, Janey. It's interesting, in Zimbabwe, Mugabe has tried to pit the Shona people against the Ndebele - but interestingly, it simply hasn't worked because there is a fundamental unity that runs deep. In SA there is a long history of ethnic violence and I suspect it's far from over - there needs to be considerable more human development and education - and a government that is not fractured.
I do certainly think that this violence harks back to something primeval - but it is also more than that - more complex - and that's the trouble in trying to understand it - it's that kind of beast that lurks within stuff, the shadow self stuff - still untamed, fearful and ferocious.
And yes, a rainbow is a pretty illusion, isn't it. But then so is everything...
I think one of the problems is, Mouse that not everyone wants the rainbow nation. I think it might be that many want only a rainbow that is a single hue.
And yes, one wonders, how much of a small blip might it take to turn humans into monsters especially when there is much in us that is already monsters - and yet much too, that is divine... Strange dualities.
I think much of the world is sheltered from much that goes on in other places, all the time, Christina - I think much gets filtered out because I suspect there is just so much one can deal with.
An excellent post AV. I don't have anything to add that is more considered than all these previous comments which are excellent. Thank you for writing this. Far more eloquent and intelligent than the majority of newspaper articles.
thats is really sad to know things like that are happening. People just dont realize that their economy is based on those who come from other countries and are willing to contribute in the way they can. People are just like that, they dont want to do anything themselves but when someone foreighn does it, they pursue him/her and ruin everything, not for those people but for themselves too!!
At a time when I have been so excited about the changes and fresh hope for my country it is so sad to read this and know that there is still so much racism and hate in this world....and so much to be done.
You are right, AV. So like kristolnacht (sp?) when the Nazis destroyed every Jew-owned shop, business, etc., then blamed it on the owners themselves, saying THEY should pay the costs involved. But they were dis-allowed being in business or owning a shop or being bankers or attorneys. Even our US newspapers bought into that propaganda and agreed.
Hitler had posters put up, all blaming the Jews for everything, while he was quietly putting the mentally and physically disabled GERMANS to death.
We will never understand how someone can torture or kill at will, but usually a strong fear is behind their actions.
I agree powerful post!
Our rainbow is missing, our dream is gone. It's so sad.
But I'm trying very hard to be positive. We've got such a beautiful country.
The thing is we must move forward, it's not happening. We must remember the past, learn from our mistakes. But the government must stop blaming the past for everything going wrong.
The crime is getting out of hand. The government must stop sitting around doing nothing. Like Bart said start with education, stop the corruption and Mbeki must sort out our own problems, he's always somewhere else, solving other problems. Hello your own country is a mess, Mr Mbeki!
This was very eye-opening. The news as far as I can see is off the radar because of the presidential primaries ... but even before that, I'm afraid we view South Africa as "finished business." Please write more on this. The voice of the blogosphere must be vocal on such matters, and you write eloquently. Thank you.
Such a bloody shame that it's happening - just makes me very, very sad.
I'm missing you -- a bunch -- and worried that you haven't posted in many days now. I hope you are okay.
Righteous post, Abby. Lachrimae mundi.
Post a Comment