
These eyes, they stare at me and haunt me...
I am constantly struck by the pain in the world – and how it permeates every aspect of humankind. And then I wonder at that word – human + kind – earthly beings amongst whom there is never really enough kindness… Whenever I drive down to the local mall, there are always people begging at the traffic lights. Usually they stand there with a piece of cardboard on which is scribbled, “No Job. 4 Kids to Feed. Please help. God Bless”. Often their faces are contorted by an excess of alcohol and meths. And their eyes…to look into their eyes is so see the numbness that has surpassed oceans and eons of pain and trauma. Once when I stopped a child came to my window – I usually avoid eye contact, there is just so much pain I can bear to look at – but this time I looked. In the eyes of a child the pain still shows – the anger, the fear, the terror are still revealed though you see from the edges how the numbness, the self-preservatory armor of anaesthesia, creeps in. So young and yet already subjected to so much abuse.
We are a strange species. We injure each other so much – and to what end? I live, as you know, in a society that has endured the most violent of injurious behaviour – and which still continues to perpetuate that violence and injury – but in different ways. But it is not just here, it is not just this point in time. Consider, as a case in point, what’s currently happening in Burma. Consider the actions of Vlad Ţepeş against Ottoman expansionism. Violence and pain seem, so tragically, an almost fundamental part of our natures. Who’d have thought to look at it like that, that it would be like that? Especially when we would so much prefer to focus on our noble and gentler natures.
But you see, here’s the thing that is constantly made obvious to me. Many of us carry – to a greater or lesser extent - some kind of pain and trauma. Inevitably it stems from our childhood. Inevitably it was linked to our parents’ or some other’s pain. It finds its roots in pain that has gone on to become accepted childrearing practice - what Alice Miller calls the poisonous pedagogy. It goes on to shape societies and systems of governance. Seldom if ever did we bring the pain upon ourselves – yet we almost always pass it on. So there it is and there we sit with it. What becomes pivotal is how we deal with our pain – if we deal with it - if we are able to deal with it. Either we handle it and heal ourselves from it – and it strikes me that those who do are in the minority – for it takes resources, support, love, courage and fortitude to mine the depths of that which injured us and move on. Or, we pass it on. We may do so by turning it inward or we may vent our spleen on those around us – whether we know them or not. We try to make our issues their issues, we fail to deal with the things that make us ache and instead, like hand grenades, we detonate outwards, spreading and scattering our pain and our fear - through one means or another. And isn’t this perhaps the root of our problems - our and society's failure or inability to take responsibility for personal traumas, issues, baggage - the stuff that we all carry to some extent or another? Of course some might say, “But I didn’t ask for this to happen to me, it’s not my fault, not my responsibility.” Actually, whether you “asked” for it or not, it’s yours and utlimately only you can take the responsiblity - with support and love and care - to deal with it. No one else can. We start with ourselves, with a single step. Perhaps that is indeed the challenge of being human – to acknowledge, call up and accept our pain - personal and collective, to deal with it and our needs and fears, to move beyond and so to stop the rot of the constant spreading of personal trauma and fear. I accept it is not always easy, that circumstances can work against us but perhaps it is a case of to each his/her own level of challenge. I don't know. All I do know is I wish we'd stop hurting others because we are hurt - it makes for far too much of a Catch-22 situation which goes on and on and on...
This is a huge, complex and multiple topic - which probably deserves an entire blog, not just one short blog post - and I accept that I'm brushing the surface and that, as always, there are many ways of looking at any one thing.
I'm not sure if the single image above qualifies for Phoctober over at Moon Topples or not - the general instructions are, well, general... but take a look and see what's happening anyway.
25 comments:
Pain, it cuts wounds into our hearts, like water carves caverns and canyons out of the hardest stone.
Indeed, passing pain from one generation to the next is a tragic flaw that will erode the fabric of humanity, if we don't stop the nonsense.
I wholeheartedly agree with your post, Vanilla. It is up to each of us to overcome the trauma earlier in our lives and bring a little happiness to someone everyday, if not ourselves. I laugh a lot and smile even more. :)
Thanks for posting this, Vanilla. :)
lovely vanilla... i resonnate.
empathy is tricky. cause sensitivity is the mother of spirituality but one needs to function in the midst of all the insane behaviours.
much love from afar...
Well, I don't know if the image qualifies for Phoctober, but I feel this is a post worth pushing the envelope for, so I'll link it anyway. I don't expect there'll be a publis outcry or anything.
There I go again, making innocuous words seem dirty for no apparent reason. "Public" outcry is what I meant.
Right in the heart of the matter, Abvanlah.
I am hopeful for change but conscious of its absence, and I understand the haunting ghosts.
Sending you some smoke,
John :)
Laughing and smiling are good medicine, JD, we need more laughter, more smiles, more kindness and compassion.
Empathy is very tricky - frequently it takes two, two don't often come to the party, A. Too often the ego clambers into the way.
Much love to you too...
Thanks, MoonT - I didn't think the image qualified either. Yes, and mind your language, dear.
Thanks for the smoke, Big John - one can but hope, one can but start with oneself.
a very in depth article, and something Ive thought about laong similar lines....
we need to heal.. we need to restore innocence and joy, we need to fill upi this dryness nad apathy with love and gentleness.
thats why Gandhi's quote makes ense.. I will be the change I want to see in this world.
AV: I've posted similarly about this but less eloquently. Knowing where to start is my conundrum. My cause as you know is Amnesty International, they're not flawless but it's step inthe right direction and it seemed more worthwhile to pour proper energy into one organisation than smatter small contributions around half a dozen each year.
It's so true that one takes their emotional baggage with them into relationships, jobs and positions of power.
As for issues closer to home, some deal with adversity, others crumble. It's up to the strong to protect the weak, not the powerful to subjugate the marginalised.
Thoughtful post. We need to keep this kind of thinking alive. Singally, we can do nothing . .combined we can become powerful.
I'd love to hear sometime how you ended up where you are. Were you born into this place? Maybe you have already told the story.
I think we hurt when we see others hurt because we are all connected in a larger body sense. But I also think we do need boundaries from others' pain so as not to be overwhelmed. It's a fine balance. I don't know how I'd do it.
Here eyes are sankpu. That's a Japanese term for when the pupil floats above the rim and the white on the bottom shows. It signifies low energy, or drugs, or other trouble.
wonderful thought provoking post and also thanks for the alice miller links, esp. the pedagogy one. right on. my consciousness was triggered on two things I've read in the past that resounded loudly - carolyn myss 'why people don't heal' (if you havent come across this do, I think you will appreciate the insights) and also maggie scarf's work -eg intimate worlds.
'life a lament in one ear and a song in the other'
greetings from the windy city, the mouse will return sunday (or monday)xxxx
A powerful piece vanilla! You cut to the centre of many parent's fears: what are we passing on to our children; besides our prejudices and politics?
What pain are we inflicting in ignorance and by actions that we don't even think about - glib comments passed but taken seriously by our kids?
I often see 'expected failure' syndrome - children who, at three, already have their future mapped out and without hope of change.
There are a few who will have the opportunity/the chance to climb out of the pit and early years practitioners can have an enormous influence, sparking the fire.
I am not sure what the figures are but those who are abused are more than likely to go on to abuse in one way or another - the greatest shame is that most of the abuse is directed at themselves.
Thank you all for reading. Every one of you makes equally observant and concerned responses.
I suppose the question for us all is how we move forward having recognised the place we are in. As Baino says, how do we make a difference - and as Colleen says, without becoming ensnared in the collective pain that is out there. I have no answers, but I do know that the line that Alice Miller takes is a powerful one. In her recent presentations I believe she has looked squarely at the US invasion of Iraq and explored the poisonous pedagogy in that instance. Her observations, you can find them via a google search, make for interesting reading.
And also, as Mystic says, Ghandi's quote is a powerful one, we start with ourselves, we become the change we want to see in the world. One step forward at a time.
Kimy, yes, I've read Myss's work but I don't know of Maggie Scarf, I shall have a peek on amazon.
The sins of the fathers, Pisces, it seems they are always with us, but it only takes one to break the cycle. So again, we start with ourselves.
Yes, Minx abusers do often go on to become abusers. But it isn't necessary - with just one enlightened nurturer, just one figure who cares somewhere in a child's life, an entire history of abuse can be averted. I think teachers and those who play similar roles in society, can make such a tremendous difference in the life of children who are abused at home. But one has to get past the "accepted child rearing practices" first. We all need to learn to think differently.
This week at LIP (www.livinginpoetry.blogspot.com) is honoring the voice of Mystic Rose..please join us and share your thoughts on Mystic Rose
Thanks ..Nasra
you know sometimes I have a doubt, whose the sinner, whose got the bad karma, the people who are suffering, or people like us who are somewhat helpless who get to see this, or people with power and ability to do a lot, and still end up being useless
Very well put Vanilla and more than thought provoking. Humans are a strange race at times.
I'm not 100% on if we, as indo-european/Western folk do in fact pass on our perjudgeships to our next generation as much as you claim.....but nonetheless I do agree with your basic premise that one learns from their parents. We all do this and to what extent we harbor that is a debate best left to the academic community. Please, I do not in any way mean to dimishish what you have brought forth. I really don't. I agree with you.
Well written AV. If we could just find a way for people to experience the power of forgiveness, understanding and selflessness, we'd have a means to end pain in the world.
Great post, Vanilla. Deep and well written.
I think you can only draw a personal line in the sand on passing on pain. And I firmly believe in random acts of kindness.
You can't cure every ill, but little acts of humanity can make a difference I believe.
Plus looking at the good things people do, they may be small, but they are there if we look. Otherwise you just feel squashed by all the ills of this world.
I came home to two boxes of pansies left on my doorstep by a friend who knew I was going to refill my window boxes for the winter. It was such a sweet surprise.
Very well written, AV, I'm all with you! Thank you for expressing these thoughts I often have myself.
What to do about it, though, that's almost infinitely difficult to answer...
This may sound trite but I was on the bus home and listening to Björk's 'Human Behaviour' today. Those lyrics are so apt. Watching people milling around and hearing the words was like being part of some surreal play. Which, I suppose, is the truth.
Rambler, I'm not sure that it is as simple as just trying to find or define who is the sinner. Perhaps we all are. Perhaps we are all waiting to save ourselves.
Ooh, no, Brian - you live where I live and you'll see how easily prejudgements are passed on. As for leaving the debate to the academic community, I have to disagree (but will send you a daisy nevertheless ;-) ). I think it is the responsibility of every one of us to consider issues like this - failure to do so leaves us exactly where we currently are.
Humans are very strange - and rather tragic too, Cailleach.
Kat, I'm always inclined to think forgiveness is overrated, but I do think we could all do with considerably more understanding, insight and self awareness - so that we realise how interconnected we are and how the pain of one impacts upon the other.
Thanks, Marie. It is a complex subject - and certainly deserves more than one post.
You're right, Apprentice there is beauty everywhere if we look for it. I recall two encounters I had with vagrants. One was after I'd locked my keys in the car and this woman came up to me begging, while her "gang" hung about not far away keeping an eye on me. I gave her some money and a lecture not to spend it on booze. She went off, bought herself some hot soup and came back and extolled my virtues! Although blotted almost out of her mind, she was funny, insightful and totally charming. A second incident was similar when two vagrants gate crashed a New Year's street party. They wanted to dance and the organisers were having a huge sense of humour failure, so I went and danced with them. They were so delighted to be included, so pleased to be part of something that was more than themselves, and although I was swamped by alcohol fumes and other less delightful odours, being just a tiny part of their lives, for just a small fraction of time, made me realise that we all harbour the same dreams and needs. We all really want to be part of one another, yet our fear keeps us apart.
I suspect that if we all worked together, Vesper, if we all worked as one, then we might find the solution a whole lot more easily.
Yep, Mellifluous Dark, it does frequently feel like we are part of a surreal play... As Cailleach said, we're a strange species...
Post a Comment