Wednesday, September 12, 2007

Darfur - what state our humanity?


In 1994 the world sat by as an estimated 800 000 people were killed in Rwanda. The powers that could have intervened to save so many lives did not. Many say the reason they did not is because Africa is of little consequence and the Rwandans had no oil...

Today the world largely sits by again as the genocide in Darfur continues. "Ethnically targeted violence, orchestrated by Khartoum, continues to be chronicled by human rights investigators, though it has certainly diminished since the height of massacres and village destruction from early 2003 through early 2005. Reports of ethnically targeted rape by Khartoum's Janjaweed militia are ongoing. The regime continues its indiscriminate aerial bombardment of African villages." (More here.)

Over a period of four years over 200 000 people have been killed by the Sudanese military dictatorship. What does this say about us, our humanity, our leaders?

The Avaaz organisation recently sent out the following message:

For four years, Sudan's military dictator, General Omar Bashir, has organized brutal militias to murder over 200,000 of his own citizens in the region of Darfur, all because a few of them dared to oppose his rule. After a massive global outcry, the killing has decreased and the UN is deploying peacekeepers - but what peace will they have to keep? Our leaders can seize this chance to press for the fair and lasting peace that the people of Darfur want, or they can appease Bashir, seek peace on the cheap, and abandon millions of Sudanese to the whims of a genocidal regime.
The US role in Sudan remains one of irony. The following report from 2005 in the Los Angeles Times states:

The Bush administration has forged a close intelligence partnership with the Islamic regime that once welcomed Osama bin Laden here, even though Sudan continues to come under harsh U.S. and international criticism for human rights violations.The Sudanese government, an unlikely ally in the U.S. fight against terror, remains on the most recent U.S. list of state sponsors of terrorism. At the same time, however, it has been providing access to terrorism suspects and sharing intelligence data with the United States. Last week, the CIA sent an executive jet here to ferry the chief of Sudan's intelligence agency to Washington for secret meetings sealing Khartoum's sensitive and previously veiled partnership with the administration, U.S. government officials confirmed.
You can read the rest of the article here.
While the US administration have been vocal in their condemnation of human rights violations,why, when they clearly hold such sway with the Sudanese government is the US unable, or unwilling, to prevent the ongoing genocide? Critics say: "We have not taken adequate measures given the enormity of the crimes because we don't want to directly confront Sudan [on Darfur] when it is cooperating on terrorism." So much for real action on human rights violations... the result of a conflict of interests perhaps...

Recently, Eric Reeves, an American academic and long time expert on Sudan condemned statements made by the US presidential envoy to Sudan Andrew Natsios to the Boston Herald in which he said that efforts by Darfur activists such as Save Darfur coalition were “more useful eight to 12 months ago” but are now outdated. Reeves said it was "not the advocates that are making peace more difficult: it’s the attitude of appeasement and accommodation represented by Natsios that is the real obstacle to peace."

Next Friday, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon will convene the "Darfur Contact Group" of 17 leaders to help set the agenda for Darfur's peace talks. This is the best hope yet for voices to triumph over violence.

Like Rwanda, the Darfur genocide is a stain on the conscience of the world. How is it that some lives are worth more than others - when surely all life is of equal worth? Or do we really believe that some of us are better than others of us? Isn't that perhaps what we say when we fail to take action when such instances of genocide unravel? Or do we think, it's far away, it's not our problem, we have problems of our own.... can't be bothered to try and make a difference, got to pay for my new SUV... Do we fail to realise and appreciate our interconnectedness, that what we do to one part of ourselves does not harm another part of ourselves...?

If the Darfur genocide bothers you and you feel the need to speak up go to Avaaz.org or Save Darfur - Take Action. If world leaders won't do the necessary or sufficient then let the people take action - or at least try to do so.

(Image courtesy of the internet.)

24 comments:

Rambler said...

so disturbing.. sometimes I fail to see what others see, in fact most of the political decisions are beyond my reasoning

Debi said...

Thanks for this, Ab Van. As you say, how does it reflect on us all that this is happening in the world?

Absolute Vanilla (and Atyllah) said...

Rambler - I think all too often political decision are about greed and power.

Debi! You're back!
Yep, it is a sad reflection that this is happening in the world - speaks volumes about humanity per se.

gregra&gar said...

Modern devotion to weapon technology enables insanity to enforce itself, reinforce it self, and perpetuate itself. If differences had to be dealt with hand to hand, there would be much more negotiation and less conflagration. In the revolutionary war, with musket loaders and ball cannons, the rate of civilian deaths was one in a hundred combat fatalities. With solid circuit, gps guidance systems and superscopes, the modern civilian mortality rate is 90 out of every 100 killed in Iraq. Banning the use and manufacture of killing technology would not restore sanity to the human race, it would just isolate its effects to two people at a time. We live in the age of remote murder where we don't even have to know what happens after the button is pushed.

kimy said...

thanks for this thoughtful and eloquent post. anything from the bush administration - phew! that tragically I expect is a hopeless cause (unless there are some hidden reservoirs of oil about). don't get me going about! thanks for all the links - who is that said 'when the people lead, the leaders will follow'?

Absolute Vanilla (and Atyllah) said...

It's a strange and violent world we live in gregra&gar - so easy to push a button or place an order that can instantly kill thousands. I suppose it makes it easier to kill when weapons technology has made leaders become so detached from the actual killing.

Hi Kimy - The line about "when the people lead, the leaders will follow' sounds like something I've read in the Tao Te Ching - when a great leader accomplishes something, the people say, "We did it." [Chapter 17]

John Eaton said...

Righteous and timely, AV@A.

Amen,

John

Verilion said...

Hi Vanilla a well made argument, and BTW Kimy, a friend of mine has recently gone to work in Sudan and guess what... there's LOADS OF OIL there! All kind of starts to fall into place doesn't it!

Baino said...

We're experiencing a flood of Sudanese refugees at the moment. The latest wave. They are not impoverished just marginalised and desperate to leave the Hell hole that is now their homeland. It's true, while we're wasting our time in Iraq (the country is doomed to civil war thanks to our involvement) Africa is forgotten. I can't help thinking that good people stand by while bad things happen - I'm one of them and it's shameful. I haven't read all the links yet but I will. Here's hoping the delegation can forge some peace although attempts in Zimbabwe have been futile other than boycotting their cricket team!

Wanderlust Scarlett said...

This travesty is one that is close to my heart. I want very much to be there, making a difference, but it is not possible at this time.

I am compelled to do what I can from here. I am very glad that you posted this; knowledge is our first step in the right direction.

Scarlett & V.

Baino said...

Correction to last - that is we'll lose to Zimbabwe in any other country as we did yesterday in Capetown but won't play them on their home soil. Hypocritical? I think so.

Absolute Vanilla (and Atyllah) said...

Thanks, John.

Yep, V, funny how you mention oil and bits of the puzzled pitter patter into place.

Baino we have floods of refugees here from all over Africa looking for a better life for themselves. SA is seen as the land of golden opportunity on their own continent, the irony is the xenophobia here is beyond staggering. A Congolese guy I was chatting to a while back told me how a bunch of his friends had been torched in their beds by locals peeved at their presence because they are seen to "steal jobs". The irony is, the refugees work really hard, the locals are deeply anti work. But that is a whole other post... As for the cricket - I'm giving it a wide berth - the rugby is enough to contend with - but yes, hypocrisy seems to be one of humanity's guiding principles...

Scarlett so long as we each do what we can from wherever we are as opposed to sitting on our hands and saying it's not our problem, then that's a start in the right direction.

Baino said...

This post really got to me. I joined Amnesty International today. I'm not sure what I can do but I just feel it's time to do something. I've always said when I sell this albatross of a property, I'll retire and give back to the community but I'm torn . . .there are so many causes, it's mindblowing as to which one to support. You've got me thinking big time Vanilla. (I buy Fair Trade coffee, does that count for anything?)

Absolute Vanilla (and Atyllah) said...

Good for you, Baino! And yeah, I'd think Fair Trade coffee counts for something :-) though mind you, there have been mutterings about the fairness of the Fair Trade group too. Got to constantly be on our toes.
Don't know if you've watched it but see if you can get hold of a copy of the movie Sometimes in April - that will really set you thinking about genocide and human rights violations.

mystic rose said...

All the tragedies that affect this world can be prevented or atleast, minimised. Its true, Rwanda could have been avoided. And so can Darfur be now.

To say that a continent or nation is not important enough is ignorance. Till we recognize that the whole world is us, is ours, what use progress? What use our evolution? if we cannot have that compassion and empathy?
Many do, but unfortunately political leaders cannot see beyond their political careers. The ego blocks their heart, and they assume that is how the citizens are.

Absolute Vanilla (and Atyllah) said...

Very true words, Mystic Rose - I think political leaders are frequently amongst the most ignorant people in the world - and as you say, are driven by massive ego needs.

Jan said...

JUst discovered you. Great blog. Hope to return!

Jon M said...

We ignore so much suffering that goes on...not good!

Absolute Vanilla (and Atyllah) said...

Hi Jan - good to see you here!

Jon - it's a mad, bad, sad world - too often.

Minx said...

The ones who hold the reins of power are the ones least qualified to lead. Unfortunately the only ones who make it to these positions are people with a strong vision of power.
If only we could put our visions of humanity together - we could accomplish much

Absolute Vanilla (and Atyllah) said...

Very true words, Minxie. I suppose it is good to know that there are some folk out there who are trying to put visions for a new humanity together - they would be good to support.

Rob said...

Great post, Vanilla. It's sad how much suffering goes ignored in the world.

The Wandering Author said...

I agree entirely with you, and am ashamed to live in the United States. However, I must point out this attitude didn't begin with Rwanda - the world ignored the tragedy of Cambodia under Pol Pot, nation after nation actively turned away refugees from Nazi Germany... the list is much longer than that, but I'm depressed already. It seems most people just don't care enough. Those of us who do need to figure out a way to scream loud enough to wake their sleeping consciences, I guess.

Oh, and to those who think Sudan is "helping" us on terrorism - considering their record, I am very sure they are simply biding their time, just as Osama did back when the US worked with him. When they turn on us, our dim-witted leaders will act all shocked and horrified. Regimes willing to commit atrocities cannot be trusted - except to be sure they will commit some fresh outrage, given time.

Absolute Vanilla (and Atyllah) said...

It seems easier to ignore suffering, doesn't it Rob - a sad indictment of our "humanity".

Hi Wandering Author, you are so right that it doesn't start with Rwanda, atrocities have been committed by humans against humans for centuries. Consider Vlad Tepes, the character upon whom Dracula was based - the heads of his enemies impaled on stakes. Oh we're not a very nice bunch at all.

The very nature of what we call "humanity" needs to change and we each need to be willing to stand up and be counted to effect that change.